% Mizar ND problem: t4_mcart_1,mcart_1,117,65 fof(dh_c1_4__mcart_1,definition, ( ~ ( c1_4__mcart_1 != k1_xboole_0 & ! [A] : ~ ( r2_hidden(A,c1_4__mcart_1) & ! [B,C,D] : ( ( r2_hidden(B,C) & r2_hidden(C,D) & r2_hidden(D,A) ) => r1_xboole_0(B,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) => ! [E] : ~ ( E != k1_xboole_0 & ! [F] : ~ ( r2_hidden(F,E) & ! [G,H,I] : ( ( r2_hidden(G,H) & r2_hidden(H,I) & r2_hidden(I,F) ) => r1_xboole_0(G,E) ) ) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c1_4__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1)]). fof(e8_4__mcart_1,assumption,( c1_4__mcart_1 != k1_xboole_0 ), introduced(assumption,[file(mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1)]). fof(e13_4__mcart_1,assumption,( ! [A] : ~ ( r2_hidden(A,c1_4__mcart_1) & ! [B,C,D] : ( ( r2_hidden(B,C) & r2_hidden(C,D) & r2_hidden(D,A) ) => r1_xboole_0(B,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ), introduced(assumption,[file(mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1)]). fof(commutativity_k2_xboole_0,theorem,( ! [A,B] : k2_xboole_0(A,B) = k2_xboole_0(B,A) ), file(xboole_0,k2_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,k2_xboole_0)]). fof(idempotence_k2_xboole_0,theorem,( ! [A,B] : k2_xboole_0(A,A) = A ), file(xboole_0,k2_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,k2_xboole_0)]). fof(symmetry_r1_xboole_0,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( r1_xboole_0(A,B) => r1_xboole_0(B,A) ) ), file(xboole_0,r1_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,r1_xboole_0)]). fof(dt_k2_xboole_0,axiom,( $true ), file(xboole_0,k2_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,k2_xboole_0)]). fof(dt_c1_4__mcart_1,assumption,( $true ), introduced(assumption,[file(mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1)]). fof(dh_c2_4__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A] : ! [B] : ( r2_hidden(B,A) <=> ( r2_hidden(B,k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)) & ? [C,D] : ( r2_hidden(C,D) & r2_hidden(D,B) & ~ r1_xboole_0(C,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) => ! [E] : ( r2_hidden(E,c2_4__mcart_1) <=> ( r2_hidden(E,k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)) & ? [F,G] : ( r2_hidden(F,G) & r2_hidden(G,E) & ~ r1_xboole_0(F,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c2_4__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1)]). fof(antisymmetry_r2_hidden,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( r2_hidden(A,B) => ~ r2_hidden(B,A) ) ), file(hidden,r2_hidden), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(hidden,r2_hidden)]). fof(dt_k3_tarski,axiom,( $true ), file(tarski,k3_tarski), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(tarski,k3_tarski)]). fof(s1_xboole_0__e1_4__mcart_1,theorem,( ! [A] : ? [B] : ! [C] : ( r2_hidden(C,B) <=> ( r2_hidden(C,k3_tarski(A)) & ? [D,E] : ( r2_hidden(D,E) & r2_hidden(E,C) & ~ r1_xboole_0(D,A) ) ) ) ), file(mcart_1,s1_xboole_0__e1_4__mcart_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(mcart_1,s1_xboole_0__e1_4__mcart_1)]). fof(e1_4__mcart_1,plain,( ? [A] : ! [B] : ( r2_hidden(B,A) <=> ( r2_hidden(B,k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)) & ? [C,D] : ( r2_hidden(C,D) & r2_hidden(D,B) & ~ r1_xboole_0(C,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) ), inference(mizar_from,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,s1_xboole_0__e1_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e1_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e1_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(dt_c2_4__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c2_4__mcart_1,e1_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(dh_c3_4__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A] : ! [B] : ( r2_hidden(B,A) <=> ( r2_hidden(B,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1))) & ? [C] : ( r2_hidden(C,B) & ~ r1_xboole_0(C,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) => ! [D] : ( r2_hidden(D,c3_4__mcart_1) <=> ( r2_hidden(D,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1))) & ? [E] : ( r2_hidden(E,D) & ~ r1_xboole_0(E,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c3_4__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1)]). fof(s1_xboole_0__e3_4__mcart_1,theorem,( ! [A] : ? [B] : ! [C] : ( r2_hidden(C,B) <=> ( r2_hidden(C,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(A))) & ? [D] : ( r2_hidden(D,C) & ~ r1_xboole_0(D,A) ) ) ) ), file(mcart_1,s1_xboole_0__e3_4__mcart_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(mcart_1,s1_xboole_0__e3_4__mcart_1)]). fof(e3_4__mcart_1,plain,( ? [A] : ! [B] : ( r2_hidden(B,A) <=> ( r2_hidden(B,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1))) & ? [C] : ( r2_hidden(C,B) & ~ r1_xboole_0(C,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) ), inference(mizar_from,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,s1_xboole_0__e3_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e3_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e3_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(dt_c3_4__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c3_4__mcart_1,e3_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(dh_c4_4__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A] : ! [B] : ( r2_hidden(B,A) <=> ( r2_hidden(B,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)))) & ~ r1_xboole_0(B,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) => ! [C] : ( r2_hidden(C,c4_4__mcart_1) <=> ( r2_hidden(C,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)))) & ~ r1_xboole_0(C,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c4_4__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c4_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(mcart_1,c4_4__mcart_1)]). fof(s1_xboole_0__e5_4__mcart_1,theorem,( ! [A] : ? [B] : ! [C] : ( r2_hidden(C,B) <=> ( r2_hidden(C,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(k3_tarski(A)))) & ~ r1_xboole_0(C,A) ) ) ), file(mcart_1,s1_xboole_0__e5_4__mcart_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(mcart_1,s1_xboole_0__e5_4__mcart_1)]). fof(e5_4__mcart_1,plain,( ? [A] : ! [B] : ( r2_hidden(B,A) <=> ( r2_hidden(B,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)))) & ~ r1_xboole_0(B,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ), inference(mizar_from,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,s1_xboole_0__e5_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e5_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e5_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(dt_c4_4__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c4_4__mcart_1,e5_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,c4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(dh_c6_4__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A] : ( r2_hidden(A,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) & r1_xboole_0(A,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ) => ( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) & r1_xboole_0(c6_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c6_4__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1)]). fof(existence_m1_subset_1,axiom,( ! [A] : ? [B] : m1_subset_1(B,A) ), file(subset_1,m1_subset_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(subset_1,m1_subset_1)]). fof(dt_m1_subset_1,axiom,( $true ), file(subset_1,m1_subset_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(subset_1,m1_subset_1)]). fof(fc2_xboole_0,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( ~ v1_xboole_0(A) => ~ v1_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(A,B)) ) ), file(xboole_0,fc2_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,fc2_xboole_0)]). fof(fc3_xboole_0,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( ~ v1_xboole_0(A) => ~ v1_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(B,A)) ) ), file(xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0)]). fof(rc1_xboole_0,theorem,( ? [A] : v1_xboole_0(A) ), file(xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0)]). fof(rc2_xboole_0,theorem,( ? [A] : ~ v1_xboole_0(A) ), file(xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0)]). fof(t2_subset,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( m1_subset_1(A,B) => ( v1_xboole_0(B) | r2_hidden(A,B) ) ) ), file(subset,t2_subset), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(subset,t2_subset)]). fof(t8_boole,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ~ ( v1_xboole_0(A) & A != B & v1_xboole_0(B) ) ), file(boole,t8_boole), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(boole,t8_boole)]). fof(dt_k1_xboole_0,axiom,( $true ), file(xboole_0,k1_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,k1_xboole_0)]). fof(fc1_xboole_0,theorem,( v1_xboole_0(k1_xboole_0) ), file(xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0)]). fof(t1_boole,theorem,( ! [A] : k2_xboole_0(A,k1_xboole_0) = A ), file(boole,t1_boole), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(boole,t1_boole)]). fof(t1_subset,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( r2_hidden(A,B) => m1_subset_1(A,B) ) ), file(subset,t1_subset), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(subset,t1_subset)]). fof(t6_boole,theorem,( ! [A] : ( v1_xboole_0(A) => A = k1_xboole_0 ) ), file(boole,t6_boole), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(boole,t6_boole)]). fof(t7_boole,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ~ ( r2_hidden(A,B) & v1_xboole_0(B) ) ), file(boole,t7_boole), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(boole,t7_boole)]). fof(t4_xboole_1,theorem,( ! [A,B,C] : k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(A,B),C) = k2_xboole_0(A,k2_xboole_0(B,C)) ), file(xboole_1,t4_xboole_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_1,t4_xboole_1)]). fof(e1_4_1__mcart_1,plain,( k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1) = k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(c2_4__mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1)),c4_4__mcart_1) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,t4_xboole_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e1_4_1__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e1_4_1__mcart_1)]]). fof(e2_4_1__mcart_1,plain,( k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(c2_4__mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1)),c4_4__mcart_1) = k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c2_4__mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,t4_xboole_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e2_4_1__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e2_4_1__mcart_1)]]). fof(e7_4__mcart_1,plain,( k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1) = k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c2_4__mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(iterative_eq,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[e1_4_1__mcart_1,e2_4_1__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e7_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e7_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(t15_xboole_1,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( k2_xboole_0(A,B) = k1_xboole_0 => A = k1_xboole_0 ) ), file(xboole_1,t15_xboole_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_1,t15_xboole_1)]). fof(e9_4__mcart_1,plain,( k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1) != k1_xboole_0 ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,t2_subset,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,t1_subset,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t7_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,dt_k1_xboole_0,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,t6_boole,e8_4__mcart_1,e7_4__mcart_1,t15_xboole_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e9_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e9_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(t1_mcart_1,theorem,( ! [A] : ~ ( A != k1_xboole_0 & ! [B] : ~ ( r2_hidden(B,A) & r1_xboole_0(B,A) ) ) ), file(mcart_1,t1_mcart_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(mcart_1,t1_mcart_1)]). fof(e10_4__mcart_1,plain,( ? [A] : ( r2_hidden(A,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) & r1_xboole_0(A,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k1_xboole_0,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,t1_subset,t6_boole,t7_boole,e9_4__mcart_1,t1_mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e10_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e10_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(dt_c6_4__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c6_4__mcart_1,e10_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e1_4_4__mcart_1,assumption,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1) ), introduced(assumption,[file(mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),axiom,file(mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1)]). fof(dh_c1_4_4__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A] : ( r2_hidden(A,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(A,c1_4__mcart_1) ) => ( r2_hidden(c1_4_4__mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_4__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c1_4_4__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c1_4_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),axiom,file(mcart_1,c1_4_4__mcart_1)]). fof(e4_4__mcart_1,plain,( ! [A] : ( r2_hidden(A,c3_4__mcart_1) <=> ( r2_hidden(A,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1))) & ? [B] : ( r2_hidden(B,A) & ~ r1_xboole_0(B,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c3_4__mcart_1,e3_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e2_4_4__mcart_1,plain,( ? [A] : ( r2_hidden(A,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(A,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t8_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e1_4_4__mcart_1,e4_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e2_4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e2_4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(dt_c1_4_4__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c1_4_4__mcart_1,e2_4_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,c1_4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c1_4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e4_4_4__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1))) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t8_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e4_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e4_4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e4_4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e3_4_4__mcart_1,plain, ( r2_hidden(c1_4_4__mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_4__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c1_4_4__mcart_1,e2_4_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e3_4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e3_4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(d4_tarski,definition,( ! [A,B] : ( B = k3_tarski(A) <=> ! [C] : ( r2_hidden(C,B) <=> ? [D] : ( r2_hidden(C,D) & r2_hidden(D,A) ) ) ) ), file(tarski,d4_tarski), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(tarski,d4_tarski)]). fof(e5_4_4__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c1_4_4__mcart_1,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)))) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e4_4_4__mcart_1,e3_4_4__mcart_1,d4_tarski]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e5_4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e5_4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e6_4__mcart_1,plain,( ! [A] : ( r2_hidden(A,c4_4__mcart_1) <=> ( r2_hidden(A,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)))) & ~ r1_xboole_0(A,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c4_4__mcart_1,e5_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e6_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e6_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e6_4_4__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c1_4_4__mcart_1,c4_4__mcart_1) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t8_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e5_4_4__mcart_1,e6_4__mcart_1,e3_4_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e6_4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e6_4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(d2_xboole_0,definition,( ! [A,B,C] : ( C = k2_xboole_0(A,B) <=> ! [D] : ( r2_hidden(D,C) <=> ( r2_hidden(D,A) | r2_hidden(D,B) ) ) ) ), file(xboole_0,d2_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,d2_xboole_0)]). fof(e7_4_4__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c1_4_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e6_4_4__mcart_1,d2_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e7_4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e7_4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e12_4__mcart_1,plain,( r1_xboole_0(c6_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c6_4__mcart_1,e10_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e12_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e12_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(t3_xboole_0,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( ~ ( ~ r1_xboole_0(A,B) & ! [C] : ~ ( r2_hidden(C,A) & r2_hidden(C,B) ) ) & ~ ( ? [C] : ( r2_hidden(C,A) & r2_hidden(C,B) ) & r1_xboole_0(A,B) ) ) ), file(xboole_0,t3_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,t3_xboole_0)]). fof(e8_4_4__mcart_1,plain,( ~ $true ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e7_4_4__mcart_1,e12_4__mcart_1,e3_4_4__mcart_1,t3_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e8_4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e8_4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(i2_4_4__mcart_1,theorem,( $true ), introduced(tautology,[file(mcart_1,i2_4_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),trivial,file(mcart_1,i2_4_4__mcart_1)]). fof(i1_4_4__mcart_1,plain,( ~ $true ), inference(conclusion,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[e8_4_4__mcart_1,i2_4_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,i1_4_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,i1_4_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e19_4__mcart_1,plain,( ~ r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1) ), inference(discharge_asm,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1]),discharge_asm(discharge,[e1_4_4__mcart_1])],[e1_4_4__mcart_1,i1_4_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e19_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e19_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e1_4_3__mcart_1,assumption,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1) ), introduced(assumption,[file(mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),axiom,file(mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1)]). fof(dh_c1_4_3__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A,B] : ( r2_hidden(A,B) & r2_hidden(B,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(A,c1_4__mcart_1) ) => ? [C] : ( r2_hidden(c1_4_3__mcart_1,C) & r2_hidden(C,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_3__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c1_4_3__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c1_4_3__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),axiom,file(mcart_1,c1_4_3__mcart_1)]). fof(e2_4__mcart_1,plain,( ! [A] : ( r2_hidden(A,c2_4__mcart_1) <=> ( r2_hidden(A,k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)) & ? [B,C] : ( r2_hidden(B,C) & r2_hidden(C,A) & ~ r1_xboole_0(B,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c2_4__mcart_1,e1_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e2_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e2_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e2_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( ? [A,B] : ( r2_hidden(A,B) & r2_hidden(B,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(A,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t8_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e1_4_3__mcart_1,e2_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e2_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e2_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(dt_c1_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c1_4_3__mcart_1,e2_4_3__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,c1_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c1_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(dh_c2_4_3__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A] : ( r2_hidden(c1_4_3__mcart_1,A) & r2_hidden(A,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_3__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ) => ( r2_hidden(c1_4_3__mcart_1,c2_4_3__mcart_1) & r2_hidden(c2_4_3__mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_3__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c2_4_3__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c2_4_3__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),axiom,file(mcart_1,c2_4_3__mcart_1)]). fof(dt_c2_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c1_4_3__mcart_1,dh_c2_4_3__mcart_1,e2_4_3__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,c2_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c2_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(e4_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t8_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e2_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e4_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e4_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(e3_4_3__mcart_1,plain, ( r2_hidden(c1_4_3__mcart_1,c2_4_3__mcart_1) & r2_hidden(c2_4_3__mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_3__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c1_4_3__mcart_1,dh_c2_4_3__mcart_1,e2_4_3__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e3_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e3_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(e5_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c2_4_3__mcart_1,k3_tarski(k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1))) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c2_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e4_4_3__mcart_1,e3_4_3__mcart_1,d4_tarski]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e5_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e5_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(e6_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c2_4_3__mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t8_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c2_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e5_4_3__mcart_1,e4_4__mcart_1,e3_4_3__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e6_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e6_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(e7_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c2_4_3__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e6_4_3__mcart_1,d2_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e7_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e7_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(e8_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( ~ r1_xboole_0(c6_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,e1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4_3__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e7_4_3__mcart_1,e3_4_3__mcart_1,t3_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e8_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e8_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(t70_xboole_1,theorem,( ! [A,B,C] : ( ~ ( ~ r1_xboole_0(A,k2_xboole_0(B,C)) & r1_xboole_0(A,B) & r1_xboole_0(A,C) ) & ~ ( ~ ( r1_xboole_0(A,B) & r1_xboole_0(A,C) ) & r1_xboole_0(A,k2_xboole_0(B,C)) ) ) ), file(xboole_1,t70_xboole_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_1,t70_xboole_1)]). fof(e9_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( ~ $true ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e1_4_3__mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,e8_4_3__mcart_1,e12_4__mcart_1,t70_xboole_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e9_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e9_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(i2_4_3__mcart_1,theorem,( $true ), introduced(tautology,[file(mcart_1,i2_4_3__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),trivial,file(mcart_1,i2_4_3__mcart_1)]). fof(i1_4_3__mcart_1,plain,( ~ $true ), inference(conclusion,[status(thm),assumptions([e1_4_3__mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[e9_4_3__mcart_1,i2_4_3__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,i1_4_3__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,i1_4_3__mcart_1)]]). fof(e17_4__mcart_1,plain,( ~ r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1) ), inference(discharge_asm,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1]),discharge_asm(discharge,[e1_4_3__mcart_1])],[e1_4_3__mcart_1,i1_4_3__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e17_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e17_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e1_4_2__mcart_1,assumption,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ), introduced(assumption,[file(mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),axiom,file(mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1)]). fof(dh_c1_4_2__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A,B,C] : ( r2_hidden(A,B) & r2_hidden(B,C) & r2_hidden(C,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(A,c1_4__mcart_1) ) => ? [D,E] : ( r2_hidden(c1_4_2__mcart_1,D) & r2_hidden(D,E) & r2_hidden(E,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c1_4_2__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c1_4_2__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),axiom,file(mcart_1,c1_4_2__mcart_1)]). fof(e2_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( ? [A,B,C] : ( r2_hidden(A,B) & r2_hidden(B,C) & r2_hidden(C,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(A,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t8_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e2_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e2_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(dt_c1_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c1_4_2__mcart_1,e2_4_2__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,c1_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c1_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(dh_c2_4_2__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A,B] : ( r2_hidden(c1_4_2__mcart_1,A) & r2_hidden(A,B) & r2_hidden(B,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ) => ? [C] : ( r2_hidden(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c2_4_2__mcart_1) & r2_hidden(c2_4_2__mcart_1,C) & r2_hidden(C,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c2_4_2__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c2_4_2__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),axiom,file(mcart_1,c2_4_2__mcart_1)]). fof(dt_c2_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c1_4_2__mcart_1,dh_c2_4_2__mcart_1,e2_4_2__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,c2_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c2_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(dh_c3_4_2__mcart_1,definition, ( ? [A] : ( r2_hidden(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c2_4_2__mcart_1) & r2_hidden(c2_4_2__mcart_1,A) & r2_hidden(A,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ) => ( r2_hidden(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c2_4_2__mcart_1) & r2_hidden(c2_4_2__mcart_1,c3_4_2__mcart_1) & r2_hidden(c3_4_2__mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c3_4_2__mcart_1),file(mcart_1,c3_4_2__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),axiom,file(mcart_1,c3_4_2__mcart_1)]). fof(dt_c3_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( $true ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c1_4_2__mcart_1,dh_c2_4_2__mcart_1,dh_c3_4_2__mcart_1,e2_4_2__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,c3_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,c3_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(e3_4_2__mcart_1,plain, ( r2_hidden(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c2_4_2__mcart_1) & r2_hidden(c2_4_2__mcart_1,c3_4_2__mcart_1) & r2_hidden(c3_4_2__mcart_1,c6_4__mcart_1) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c1_4_2__mcart_1,dh_c2_4_2__mcart_1,dh_c3_4_2__mcart_1,e2_4_2__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e3_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e3_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(e4_4_2__mcart_1,plain, ( r2_hidden(c3_4_2__mcart_1,k3_tarski(c1_4__mcart_1)) & ~ r1_xboole_0(c1_4_2__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c2_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c3_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e3_4_2__mcart_1,d4_tarski]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e4_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e4_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(e5_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c3_4_2__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t8_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c3_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e4_4_2__mcart_1,e2_4__mcart_1,e3_4_2__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e5_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e5_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(e6_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c3_4_2__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4_2__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e5_4_2__mcart_1,d2_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e6_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e6_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(e7_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c3_4_2__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4_2__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e6_4_2__mcart_1,d2_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e7_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e7_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(e8_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c3_4_2__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e7_4_2__mcart_1,d2_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e8_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e8_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(e9_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( ~ $true ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4_2__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e8_4_2__mcart_1,e12_4__mcart_1,e3_4_2__mcart_1,t3_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,e9_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e9_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(i2_4_2__mcart_1,theorem,( $true ), introduced(tautology,[file(mcart_1,i2_4_2__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.65),trivial,file(mcart_1,i2_4_2__mcart_1)]). fof(i1_4_2__mcart_1,plain,( ~ $true ), inference(conclusion,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e1_4_2__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1])],[e9_4_2__mcart_1,i2_4_2__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.65),file(mcart_1,i1_4_2__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,i1_4_2__mcart_1)]]). fof(e14_4__mcart_1,plain,( ~ r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ), inference(discharge_asm,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,e13_4__mcart_1]),discharge_asm(discharge,[e1_4_2__mcart_1])],[e1_4_2__mcart_1,i1_4_2__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e14_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e14_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e11_4__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c1_4__mcart_1,c2_4__mcart_1),c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(consider,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dh_c6_4__mcart_1,e10_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e11_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e11_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e15_4__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(k2_xboole_0(c2_4__mcart_1,c3_4__mcart_1),c4_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e13_4__mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e14_4__mcart_1,e7_4__mcart_1,e11_4__mcart_1,d2_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e15_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e15_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e16_4__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(c2_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(c3_4__mcart_1,c4_4__mcart_1))) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e13_4__mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e15_4__mcart_1,t4_xboole_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e16_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e16_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e18_4__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,k2_xboole_0(c3_4__mcart_1,c4_4__mcart_1)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e13_4__mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e17_4__mcart_1,e16_4__mcart_1,d2_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e18_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e18_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e20_4__mcart_1,plain,( r2_hidden(c6_4__mcart_1,c4_4__mcart_1) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e13_4__mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t1_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,fc2_xboole_0,fc3_xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,t8_boole,commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e19_4__mcart_1,e18_4__mcart_1,d2_xboole_0]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e20_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e20_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e21_4__mcart_1,plain,( ~ r1_xboole_0(c6_4__mcart_1,c1_4__mcart_1) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e13_4__mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_k1_xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0,t8_boole,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_m1_subset_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t6_boole,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,dt_k3_tarski,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,t1_subset,t7_boole,e20_4__mcart_1,e6_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e21_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e21_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(e22_4__mcart_1,plain,( ~ $true ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([e13_4__mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[commutativity_k2_xboole_0,idempotence_k2_xboole_0,symmetry_r1_xboole_0,dt_k2_xboole_0,dt_c1_4__mcart_1,dt_c2_4__mcart_1,dt_c3_4__mcart_1,dt_c4_4__mcart_1,dt_c6_4__mcart_1,e21_4__mcart_1,e7_4__mcart_1,e12_4__mcart_1,t70_xboole_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,e22_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,e22_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(i4_4__mcart_1,theorem,( $true ), introduced(tautology,[file(mcart_1,i4_4__mcart_1)]), [interesting(0.8),trivial,file(mcart_1,i4_4__mcart_1)]). fof(i3_4__mcart_1,plain,( ~ $true ), inference(conclusion,[status(thm),assumptions([e13_4__mcart_1,e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[e22_4__mcart_1,i4_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,i3_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,i3_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(i2_4__mcart_1,plain,( ? [A] : ( r2_hidden(A,c1_4__mcart_1) & ! [B,C,D] : ( ( r2_hidden(B,C) & r2_hidden(C,D) & r2_hidden(D,A) ) => r1_xboole_0(B,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ), inference(discharge_asm,[status(thm),assumptions([e8_4__mcart_1,dt_c1_4__mcart_1]),discharge_asm(discharge,[e13_4__mcart_1])],[e13_4__mcart_1,i3_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,i2_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,i2_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(i1_4__mcart_1,plain,( ~ ( c1_4__mcart_1 != k1_xboole_0 & ! [A] : ~ ( r2_hidden(A,c1_4__mcart_1) & ! [B,C,D] : ( ( r2_hidden(B,C) & r2_hidden(C,D) & r2_hidden(D,A) ) => r1_xboole_0(B,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) ), inference(discharge_asm,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_4__mcart_1]),discharge_asm(discharge,[e8_4__mcart_1])],[e8_4__mcart_1,i2_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(mcart_1,i1_4__mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,i1_4__mcart_1)]]). fof(i1_4_tmp__mcart_1,plain,( ~ ( c1_4__mcart_1 != k1_xboole_0 & ! [A] : ~ ( r2_hidden(A,c1_4__mcart_1) & ! [B,C,D] : ( ( r2_hidden(B,C) & r2_hidden(C,D) & r2_hidden(D,A) ) => r1_xboole_0(B,c1_4__mcart_1) ) ) ) ), inference(discharge_asm,[status(thm),assumptions([]),discharge_asm(discharge,[dt_c1_4__mcart_1])],[dt_c1_4__mcart_1,i1_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(1),t4_mcart_1]). fof(t4_mcart_1,theorem,( ! [A] : ~ ( A != k1_xboole_0 & ! [B] : ~ ( r2_hidden(B,A) & ! [C,D,E] : ( ( r2_hidden(C,D) & r2_hidden(D,E) & r2_hidden(E,B) ) => r1_xboole_0(C,A) ) ) ) ), inference(let,[status(thm),assumptions([])],[i1_4_tmp__mcart_1,dh_c1_4__mcart_1]), [interesting(1),file(mcart_1,t4_mcart_1),[file(mcart_1,t4_mcart_1)]]).