% Mizar ND problem: t1_altcat_3,altcat_3,60,43 fof(dh_c1_5__altcat_3,definition, ( ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3) & v12_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3) & l2_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3) ) => ! [A] : ( m1_subset_1(A,u1_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3)) => ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,A),c1_5__altcat_3,A,A) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,A),c1_5__altcat_3,A,A) ) ) ) => ! [B] : ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(B) & v12_altcat_1(B) & l2_altcat_1(B) ) => ! [C] : ( m1_subset_1(C,u1_struct_0(B)) => ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(B,C),B,C,C) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(B,C),B,C,C) ) ) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c1_5__altcat_3),file(altcat_3,c1_5__altcat_3)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(altcat_3,c1_5__altcat_3)]). fof(dh_c2_5__altcat_3,definition, ( ( m1_subset_1(c2_5__altcat_3,u1_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3)) => ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) ) ) => ! [A] : ( m1_subset_1(A,u1_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3)) => ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,A),c1_5__altcat_3,A,A) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,A),c1_5__altcat_3,A,A) ) ) ), introduced(definition,[new_symbol(c2_5__altcat_3),file(altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3)]). fof(existence_l1_altcat_1,axiom,( ? [A] : l1_altcat_1(A) ), file(altcat_1,l1_altcat_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_1,l1_altcat_1)]). fof(existence_l1_struct_0,axiom,( ? [A] : l1_struct_0(A) ), file(struct_0,l1_struct_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(struct_0,l1_struct_0)]). fof(dt_l1_altcat_1,axiom,( ! [A] : ( l1_altcat_1(A) => l1_struct_0(A) ) ), file(altcat_1,l1_altcat_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_1,l1_altcat_1)]). fof(dt_l1_struct_0,axiom,( $true ), file(struct_0,l1_struct_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(struct_0,l1_struct_0)]). fof(existence_l2_altcat_1,axiom,( ? [A] : l2_altcat_1(A) ), file(altcat_1,l2_altcat_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_1,l2_altcat_1)]). fof(existence_m1_subset_1,axiom,( ! [A] : ? [B] : m1_subset_1(B,A) ), file(subset_1,m1_subset_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(subset_1,m1_subset_1)]). fof(dt_k1_altcat_1,axiom,( $true ), file(altcat_1,k1_altcat_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_1,k1_altcat_1)]). fof(dt_k8_altcat_1,axiom,( ! [A,B] : ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(A) & v12_altcat_1(A) & l2_altcat_1(A) & m1_subset_1(B,u1_struct_0(A)) ) => m1_subset_1(k8_altcat_1(A,B),k1_altcat_1(A,B,B)) ) ), file(altcat_1,k8_altcat_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_1,k8_altcat_1)]). fof(dt_l2_altcat_1,axiom,( ! [A] : ( l2_altcat_1(A) => l1_altcat_1(A) ) ), file(altcat_1,l2_altcat_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_1,l2_altcat_1)]). fof(dt_m1_subset_1,axiom,( $true ), file(subset_1,m1_subset_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(subset_1,m1_subset_1)]). fof(dt_u1_struct_0,axiom,( $true ), file(struct_0,u1_struct_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(struct_0,u1_struct_0)]). fof(dt_c1_5__altcat_3,assumption, ( ~ v3_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3) & v12_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3) & l2_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3) ), introduced(assumption,[file(altcat_3,c1_5__altcat_3)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(altcat_3,c1_5__altcat_3)]). fof(dt_c2_5__altcat_3,assumption,( m1_subset_1(c2_5__altcat_3,u1_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3)) ), introduced(assumption,[file(altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3)]), [interesting(0.8),axiom,file(altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3)]). fof(dt_k5_altcat_1,axiom,( ! [A,B,C,D,E,F] : ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(A) & l2_altcat_1(A) & m1_subset_1(B,u1_struct_0(A)) & m1_subset_1(C,u1_struct_0(A)) & m1_subset_1(D,u1_struct_0(A)) & m1_subset_1(E,k1_altcat_1(A,B,C)) & m1_subset_1(F,k1_altcat_1(A,C,D)) ) => m1_subset_1(k5_altcat_1(A,B,C,D,E,F),k1_altcat_1(A,B,D)) ) ), file(altcat_1,k5_altcat_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_1,k5_altcat_1)]). fof(antisymmetry_r2_hidden,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( r2_hidden(A,B) => ~ r2_hidden(B,A) ) ), file(hidden,r2_hidden), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(hidden,r2_hidden)]). fof(t1_subset,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( r2_hidden(A,B) => m1_subset_1(A,B) ) ), file(subset,t1_subset), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(subset,t1_subset)]). fof(cc1_funct_1,theorem,( ! [A] : ( v1_xboole_0(A) => v1_funct_1(A) ) ), file(funct_1,cc1_funct_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(funct_1,cc1_funct_1)]). fof(rc1_xboole_0,theorem,( ? [A] : v1_xboole_0(A) ), file(xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,rc1_xboole_0)]). fof(rc2_xboole_0,theorem,( ? [A] : ~ v1_xboole_0(A) ), file(xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0)]). fof(t2_subset,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ( m1_subset_1(A,B) => ( v1_xboole_0(B) | r2_hidden(A,B) ) ) ), file(subset,t2_subset), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(subset,t2_subset)]). fof(t7_boole,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ~ ( r2_hidden(A,B) & v1_xboole_0(B) ) ), file(boole,t7_boole), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(boole,t7_boole)]). fof(t8_boole,theorem,( ! [A,B] : ~ ( v1_xboole_0(A) & A != B & v1_xboole_0(B) ) ), file(boole,t8_boole), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(boole,t8_boole)]). fof(dt_k1_xboole_0,axiom,( $true ), file(xboole_0,k1_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,k1_xboole_0)]). fof(fc1_xboole_0,theorem,( v1_xboole_0(k1_xboole_0) ), file(xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(xboole_0,fc1_xboole_0)]). fof(t6_boole,theorem,( ! [A] : ( v1_xboole_0(A) => A = k1_xboole_0 ) ), file(boole,t6_boole), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(boole,t6_boole)]). fof(t23_altcat_1,theorem,( ! [A] : ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(A) & v12_altcat_1(A) & l2_altcat_1(A) ) => ! [B] : ( m1_subset_1(B,u1_struct_0(A)) => r2_hidden(k8_altcat_1(A,B),k1_altcat_1(A,B,B)) ) ) ), file(altcat_1,t23_altcat_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_1,t23_altcat_1)]). fof(e1_5__altcat_3,plain,( k1_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) != k1_xboole_0 ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_5__altcat_3,dt_c2_5__altcat_3])],[existence_l1_altcat_1,existence_l1_struct_0,dt_l1_altcat_1,dt_l1_struct_0,cc1_funct_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t8_boole,antisymmetry_r2_hidden,existence_l2_altcat_1,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_k1_altcat_1,dt_k1_xboole_0,dt_k8_altcat_1,dt_l2_altcat_1,dt_m1_subset_1,dt_u1_struct_0,dt_c1_5__altcat_3,dt_c2_5__altcat_3,fc1_xboole_0,t1_subset,t6_boole,t7_boole,t23_altcat_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(altcat_3,e1_5__altcat_3),[file(altcat_3,e1_5__altcat_3)]]). fof(d19_altcat_1,definition,( ! [A] : ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(A) & v12_altcat_1(A) & l2_altcat_1(A) ) => ! [B] : ( m1_subset_1(B,u1_struct_0(A)) => ! [C] : ( m1_subset_1(C,k1_altcat_1(A,B,B)) => ( C = k8_altcat_1(A,B) <=> ! [D] : ( m1_subset_1(D,u1_struct_0(A)) => ( k1_altcat_1(A,B,D) != k1_xboole_0 => ! [E] : ( m1_subset_1(E,k1_altcat_1(A,B,D)) => k5_altcat_1(A,B,B,D,C,E) = E ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ), file(altcat_1,d19_altcat_1), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_1,d19_altcat_1)]). fof(e2_5__altcat_3,plain,( k5_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3)) = k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_5__altcat_3,dt_c2_5__altcat_3])],[antisymmetry_r2_hidden,t1_subset,existence_l1_altcat_1,existence_l1_struct_0,dt_l1_altcat_1,dt_l1_struct_0,cc1_funct_1,rc1_xboole_0,rc2_xboole_0,t2_subset,t7_boole,t8_boole,existence_l2_altcat_1,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_k1_altcat_1,dt_k1_xboole_0,dt_k5_altcat_1,dt_k8_altcat_1,dt_l2_altcat_1,dt_m1_subset_1,dt_u1_struct_0,dt_c1_5__altcat_3,dt_c2_5__altcat_3,fc1_xboole_0,t6_boole,e1_5__altcat_3,d19_altcat_1]), [interesting(0.8),file(altcat_3,e2_5__altcat_3),[file(altcat_3,e2_5__altcat_3)]]). fof(d1_altcat_3,definition,( ! [A] : ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(A) & v12_altcat_1(A) & l2_altcat_1(A) ) => ! [B] : ( m1_subset_1(B,u1_struct_0(A)) => ! [C] : ( m1_subset_1(C,u1_struct_0(A)) => ! [D] : ( m1_subset_1(D,k1_altcat_1(A,B,C)) => ! [E] : ( m1_subset_1(E,k1_altcat_1(A,C,B)) => ( r1_altcat_3(A,B,C,D,E) <=> k5_altcat_1(A,C,B,C,E,D) = k8_altcat_1(A,C) ) ) ) ) ) ) ), file(altcat_3,d1_altcat_3), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_3,d1_altcat_3)]). fof(e3_5__altcat_3,plain, ( r1_altcat_3(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3)) & r1_altcat_3(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3)) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_5__altcat_3,dt_c2_5__altcat_3])],[existence_l1_altcat_1,existence_l1_struct_0,dt_l1_altcat_1,dt_l1_struct_0,existence_l2_altcat_1,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_k1_altcat_1,dt_k5_altcat_1,dt_k8_altcat_1,dt_l2_altcat_1,dt_m1_subset_1,dt_u1_struct_0,dt_c1_5__altcat_3,dt_c2_5__altcat_3,e2_5__altcat_3,d1_altcat_3]), [interesting(0.8),file(altcat_3,e3_5__altcat_3),[file(altcat_3,e3_5__altcat_3)]]). fof(d2_altcat_3,definition,( ! [A] : ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(A) & v12_altcat_1(A) & l2_altcat_1(A) ) => ! [B] : ( m1_subset_1(B,u1_struct_0(A)) => ! [C] : ( m1_subset_1(C,u1_struct_0(A)) => ! [D] : ( m1_subset_1(D,k1_altcat_1(A,B,C)) => ( v1_altcat_3(D,A,B,C) <=> ? [E] : ( m1_subset_1(E,k1_altcat_1(A,C,B)) & r1_altcat_3(A,B,C,D,E) ) ) ) ) ) ) ), file(altcat_3,d2_altcat_3), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_3,d2_altcat_3)]). fof(d3_altcat_3,definition,( ! [A] : ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(A) & v12_altcat_1(A) & l2_altcat_1(A) ) => ! [B] : ( m1_subset_1(B,u1_struct_0(A)) => ! [C] : ( m1_subset_1(C,u1_struct_0(A)) => ! [D] : ( m1_subset_1(D,k1_altcat_1(A,B,C)) => ( v2_altcat_3(D,A,B,C) <=> ? [E] : ( m1_subset_1(E,k1_altcat_1(A,C,B)) & r1_altcat_3(A,C,B,E,D) ) ) ) ) ) ) ), file(altcat_3,d3_altcat_3), [interesting(0.9),axiom,file(altcat_3,d3_altcat_3)]). fof(e4_5__altcat_3,plain, ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) ), inference(mizar_by,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_5__altcat_3,dt_c2_5__altcat_3])],[existence_l1_altcat_1,existence_l1_struct_0,dt_l1_altcat_1,dt_l1_struct_0,existence_l2_altcat_1,existence_m1_subset_1,dt_k1_altcat_1,dt_k8_altcat_1,dt_l2_altcat_1,dt_m1_subset_1,dt_u1_struct_0,dt_c1_5__altcat_3,dt_c2_5__altcat_3,e3_5__altcat_3,d2_altcat_3,d3_altcat_3]), [interesting(0.8),file(altcat_3,e4_5__altcat_3),[file(altcat_3,e4_5__altcat_3)]]). fof(i3_5__altcat_3,theorem,( $true ), introduced(tautology,[file(altcat_3,i3_5__altcat_3)]), [interesting(0.8),trivial,file(altcat_3,i3_5__altcat_3)]). fof(i2_5__altcat_3,plain, ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) ), inference(conclusion,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_5__altcat_3,dt_c2_5__altcat_3])],[e4_5__altcat_3,i3_5__altcat_3]), [interesting(0.8),file(altcat_3,i2_5__altcat_3),[file(altcat_3,i2_5__altcat_3)]]). fof(i2_5_tmp__altcat_3,plain, ( m1_subset_1(c2_5__altcat_3,u1_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3)) => ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3),c1_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3,c2_5__altcat_3) ) ), inference(discharge_asm,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_5__altcat_3]),discharge_asm(discharge,[dt_c2_5__altcat_3])],[dt_c2_5__altcat_3,i2_5__altcat_3]), [interesting(0.8),i1_5__altcat_3]). fof(i1_5__altcat_3,plain,( ! [A] : ( m1_subset_1(A,u1_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3)) => ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,A),c1_5__altcat_3,A,A) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,A),c1_5__altcat_3,A,A) ) ) ), inference(let,[status(thm),assumptions([dt_c1_5__altcat_3])],[i2_5_tmp__altcat_3,dh_c2_5__altcat_3]), [interesting(0.8),file(altcat_3,i1_5__altcat_3),[file(altcat_3,i1_5__altcat_3)]]). fof(i1_5_tmp__altcat_3,plain, ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3) & v12_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3) & l2_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3) ) => ! [A] : ( m1_subset_1(A,u1_struct_0(c1_5__altcat_3)) => ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,A),c1_5__altcat_3,A,A) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(c1_5__altcat_3,A),c1_5__altcat_3,A,A) ) ) ), inference(discharge_asm,[status(thm),assumptions([]),discharge_asm(discharge,[dt_c1_5__altcat_3])],[dt_c1_5__altcat_3,i1_5__altcat_3]), [interesting(1),t1_altcat_3]). fof(t1_altcat_3,theorem,( ! [A] : ( ( ~ v3_struct_0(A) & v12_altcat_1(A) & l2_altcat_1(A) ) => ! [B] : ( m1_subset_1(B,u1_struct_0(A)) => ( v1_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(A,B),A,B,B) & v2_altcat_3(k8_altcat_1(A,B),A,B,B) ) ) ) ), inference(let,[status(thm),assumptions([])],[i1_5_tmp__altcat_3,dh_c1_5__altcat_3]), [interesting(1),file(altcat_3,t1_altcat_3),[file(altcat_3,t1_altcat_3)]]).