Paper Review Form / Comments for Author IJAIT Special Issue on Empirically Successfull First Order Reasoning Title: Authors: 1. How RELEVANT is this paper for the special issue? In particular, does it describe empirically successful first order reasoning? [ ] Very relevant [ ] Moderately relevant [ ] Not relevant Comments: 2. How SIGNIFICANT is this paper? [ ] Very significant [ ] Moderately significant [ ] Not significant Comments: 3. How ORIGINAL is this paper? [ ] Very original [ ] Moderately original [ ] Not original Comments: 4. Is this paper technically SOUND? [ ] Yes [ ] Seems valid, but did not check completely [ ] Has minor errors [ ] Has major errors Comments: 5. How well is this paper PRESENTED? Good Average Poor Overall organisation [ ] [ ] [ ] English [ ] [ ] [ ] Readability [ ] [ ] [ ] Comments: 6. My overall recommendation is: [ ] Strong accept [ ] Weak accept [ ] Weak reject [ ] Strong reject 7. Further comments, advice or explanations (Specific and constructive, especially with respect to any negative judgements above.) 8. My Confidence about the review: [ ] Very confident [ ] Confident [ ] Fairly confident [ ] Not confident Comments: -------------------------------------------------------------- Anything below this line will be seen by the editors only. Reviewer: 9. Additional confidential remarks?