ATP System Results Summary
for the
TPTP Problem Library

collected by Geoff Sutcliffe
geoff@cs.miami.edu
and Christian Suttner
suttner@informatik.tu-muenchen.de

Since the first release of the TPTP Problem Library in 1993, many researchers have used the TPTP as an appropriate and convenient basis for ATP system evaluation. Some researchers, who have tested their ATP systems over the entire TPTP, have made their result data available. The data has been collected, and is used for determining system ratings, system recommendations, and the TPTP problem ratings. Currently we have data for the systems listed below.

The testing performed is summarized below.


Summary of Testing Performed

Mon Nov 17 02:01:02 EST 2008

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : SPTHEO m256n1
People             : Christian Suttner
URL                : http://wwwjessen.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~suttner/sptheo.html
References         : [Sut95] Suttner (1995), Parallelization of Search-based Sy
TPTP release       : v1.1.3
tptp2X flags       : -f setheo (No use of clause type information)
CPU                : HP 720
RAM size           : 32 MByte
Operating system   : HP-UX 9.X
Implementation     : C and PVM. Compiler: HP-UX cc. Flags: -c -g -o
Resource limits    : 20 seconds for task generation. 20 seconds per task
Settings/flags     : -cons -ir -m 256 for task generation (i.e., 256 tasks
                     requested).
                     -cons -dr for task processing. 1 processor used (time
                     sharing).
Results format     :     Solns    TotTime  APnTime  PEnWork  APnWork  PL      m
Results values     : Solns   -  P and number of proofs found
                             or TMO-Non
                             or ERR-Non (X), where X indicates the type of error.
                     TotTime - Wall clock time for parallel system, with 0
                               communication time, in seconds.
                     APnWork - Task generation time plus accumulated search
                               times (summed over all processors), in seconds.
                     PEnTime - Number of inferences (generation + 1st proof
                               task)
                     APnWork - Accumulated number of inferences (summed over
                               all processors).
                     PL      - Proof length of first proof found (not shortest)
                     m       - Number of tasks generated
Results summary    : 1339 problems (2652 in TPTP v1.1.3, 1313 since Bugfixed)
                        14 IAP-Non
                       567 TMO-Non
                       758 UNS-Ass
                      1325 tested (99%)
                       758 solutions
                       57% success, over those tested
                       57% success, overall
Comments           : Not tested on problems known to be satisfiable.
                   : If a proof is found in the sequential task generation
                     phase, CPUapn and APnWork are meaningless and marked with
                     "-". CPUtot and PEnWork then refer to task generation.
                   : Some satisfiable problems were not_tested. They are
                     labelled "satisfiable".
                   : The problems with "Error" results exceeded the capacity
                     of some component of SETHEO.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : CLIN 1.0
People             : Shie-Jue Lee
URL                : ftp.cs.unc.edu:pub/projects/mi/clin/prover.tar.Z
                     http://www.cs.unc.edu/mi/mi-provers.html
References         : [Lee90] Lee (1990), CLIN: An Automated Reasoning System Us
                   : [LP92]  Lee & Plaisted (1992), Eliminating Duplication wit
TPTP release       : v1.1.3
tptp2X flags       : -f sprfn (No use of clause type information)
CPU                : RS/6000 550
RAM size           : 512MB / 1024MB
Operating system   : AIX 3.2.5
Implementation     : Prolog. Compiler: ECLiPSe 3.4.5. Flags: nodbgcomp
Resource limits    : 1800 seconds
Settings/flags     : assign(support_list,[f]). set(slidepriority).
                     Maximum clause size method.
Results format     :     Solns    TotTime  ModTime           Clauses
Results values     : Solns   -  P and number of proofs found
                             or M and number of models found
                             or TMO-Non
                             or var_lim (limit of 20 distinct variables
                                         exceeded)
                             or cls_lim (limit of 1600 input clauses exceeded)
                     TotTime - CPU time, in seconds
                     Clauses - Number of clauses retained
Results summary    : 1339 problems (2652 in TPTP v1.1.3, 1313 since Bugfixed)
                         4 ERR-Non
                       666 TMO-Non
                       660 UNS-Ass
                         9 SAT-Ass
                      1339 tested (100%)
                       669 solutions
                       50% success, over those tested
                       50% success, overall
Comments           : CLIN automatically switches to All support and the Maximum
                     clause size method for propositional problems.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : CLIN-E 0.35FM
People             : Geoff Alexander
URL                :
References         : [Ale95] Alexander (1995), Proving First-Order Equality The
TPTP release       : v1.1.3
tptp2X flags       : -f sprfn (No use of clause type information)
CPU                : RS/6000 550
RAM size           : 512MB / 1024MB
Operating system   : AIX 3.2.5
Implementation     : C++. Compiler: IBM C Set++. Flags: -03 -qinlglue.
Resource limits    : 1800 seconds
Settings/flags     : Forward support. Maximum clause size method.
                     Unit literal deletion on. Unit literal subsumption on.
Results format     :     Solns    TotTime  ModTime   Memory  Clauses
Results values     : Solns   -  P and number of proofs found
                             or M and number of models found
                             or TMO-Non
                     TotTime - CPU time, in seconds
                     Memory  - Memory used, in K
                     Clauses - Number of clauses retained
Results summary    : 1339 problems (2652 in TPTP v1.1.3, 1313 since Bugfixed)
                       787 TMO-Non
                       543 UNS-Ass
                         9 SAT-Ass
                      1339 tested (100%)
                       552 solutions
                       41% success, over those tested
                       41% success, overall
Comments           : CLIN-E automatically switches to All support and the Sum
                     clause size method for propositional problems.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : CLIN-S 1.0+
People             : Heng Chu
URL                : ftp.cs.unc.edu:pub/projects/mi/clin-s/*
                     http://www.cs.unc.edu/Research/mi/mi-provers.html
References         : [CP94]  Chu & Plaisted (1994), Semantically Guided First-o
TPTP release       : v1.1.3
tptp2X flags       : -f sprfn ??
                     (No use of clause type information)
CPU                : DEC station 5000/120
RAM size           : ??
Operating system   : ??
Implementation     : Prolog. Compiler: Quintus. Flags: ??.
Resource limits    : 1000 seconds ?MEMORY?
Settings/flags     : FL (Model literal filtering) on,
                     NP (Natural replacement on model literals) on,
                     TR (Simple term rewriting on model literals) off,
                     MP (Minimal replacement on model literals) on,
                     RR (Rough resolution) on,
                     UR (UR resolution) on.
                     Backward support = Using the all positive model.
Results format     :     Solns       Time            Rounds  Clauses Backtracks
Results values     : Solns     -  P(XX) and number of proofs found, where XX
                                  indicates how the proof was found, one of:
                                  HM=Hyper linking,    MF=Model Finding,
                                  RR=Rough Resolution, US=Unit Simplification,
                                  UR=UR resolution.
                               or M and number of models found
                               or TMO-Non
                               or ERR-Non (UNK-Non error)
                               or unsound_model
                     Time      - CPU time, in seconds
                     Rounds    - Number of hyper-linking rounds
                     Clauses   - Number of clauses retained
                     Backtrack - Number of backtrackings caused by FL,NP,TR,MP,
                                 and UR (see Settings/flags above).
Results summary    : 1339 problems (2652 in TPTP v1.1.3, 1313 since Bugfixed)
                        78 NTT-Non
                        25 ERR-Non
                       604 TMO-Non
                       632 UNS-Ass
                      1261 tested (94%)
                       632 solutions
                       50% success, over those tested
                       47% success, overall
Comments           : Hardware used was not constant; other similar machines
                     were also used.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : CLIN-S 1.0-
TPTP release       : v1.1.3
Settings/flags     : FL (Model literal filtering) on,
                     NP (Natural replacement on model literals) on,
                     TR (Simple term rewriting on model literals) off,
                     MP (Minimal replacement on model literals) on,
                     RR (Rough resolution) on,
                     UR (UR resolution) on.
                     Forward support = Using the all negative model.
Results summary    : 1339 problems (2652 in TPTP v1.1.3, 1313 since Bugfixed)
                        19 NTT-Non
                        28 ERR-Non
                       682 TMO-Non
                       610 UNS-Ass
                      1320 tested (99%)
                       610 solutions
                       46% success, over those tested
                       46% success, overall
Comments           : See CLIN-S 1.0+
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : LINUS 1.0.1
People             : Reinhold Letz
URL                :
References         : [Let97] Letz (1997), LINUS: A Link Instantiation Prover wi
TPTP release       : v1.1.3
tptp2X flags       : -f setheo (No use of clause type information)
CPU                : Sparc 10
RAM size           : 128 Mb
Operating system   : Solaris 2.4
Implementation     : LISP. Compiler: Allegro Common Lisp 4.2. Flags: ??.
Resource limits    : 300 seconds
Settings/flags     : increase_rate = 1.5 (general weighting factor).
                     unit_div = 2        (weighting factor for units).
                     non_unit_mult = 1   (weighting factor for non-units).
                     no dynamic clause splitting
Results format     :     Solns       Time         GroundCls  UnitCls Inferences
Results values     : Solns      - P(X) and number of proofs found, where X = S
                                  for proofs found at the propositional level,
                                  X = U for proofs found by the unit module.
                               or M and number of models found
                               or TMO-Non
                     Time       - CPU time, in seconds
                     GroundCls  - Number of ground clauses in P(S) proofs
                     UnitCls    - Number of unit clauses in P(S) proofs
                     Inferences - Number of inference steps in proofs
Results summary    : 1339 problems (2652 in TPTP v1.1.3, 1313 since Bugfixed)
                       594 TMO-Non
                       736 UNS-Ass
                         9 SAT-Ass
                      1339 tested (100%)
                       745 solutions
                       56% success, over those tested
                       56% success, overall
Comments           : For unit proofs (P(U)) the number of inferences is
                     currently missing. In a future version of LINUS it will be
                     given.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : DISCOUNT 2.0-GL
People             : Stephan Schulz (Proof protocols, Learning)
                     Joerg Denzinger (Distribution concept, theory for
                     existentially qualified goals)
                     Werner Pitz (Implementation of inference engine and
                     distribution scheme)
                     Martin Kronenburg (Planning component, his domain
                     recognition engine is reused by the learning system)
URL                :
References         : [DS96]  Denzinger & Schulz (1996), Learning Domain Knowled
TPTP release       : v1.2.1
Tested on SPCs     : UEQ
tptp2X flags       : -f otter (No use of clause type information)
CPU                : SparcStation 10, 50MHz sun4m (SuperSparc Processor)
RAM size           : 128MB
Operating system   : Solaris 2.5.1
Implementation     : C. Compiler: gcc 2.4.5 Flags: -O2 -D SPARC
Resource limits    : 150 seconds
Settings/flags     : -I 5 -D 1 -G 15 -R 2 -T 1 -A -3 -B 1500 -x c_global_learn
Results format     :     Solns       Time  SrhTime
Results values     : Solns   -  P(X) and number of proofs found
                             or M(X) and the number of models found, where X is
                                "C" when the goal is universally quantified,
                                and "P" when the goal is existentially
                                quantified and thus overlapping into the goal
                                is performed.
                             or TMO-Non
                     Time    - CPU time, in seconds
                     SrhTime - Time in proof search, in seconds
Results summary    : 1692 problems (2752 in TPTP v1.2.1, 1060 since Bugfixed)
                      1330 IAP-Non
                       106 TMO-Non
                       255 UNS-Ass
                         1 SAT-Ass
                       362 tested (21%)
                       256 solutions
                       71% success, over those tested
                       15% success, overall
Comments           : Used a knowledge base (implicitly named "KNOWLEDGE")
                     generated from 664 proofs/226 problems
                   : PCL, the "Proof Communication Language" is currently
                     supported only for universally quantified goals.
                   : Various other people work on DISCOUNT. In particular, the
                     learning system profits from proofs found with the
                     distributed system and Matthias Fuchs' analogical learning.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : PROTEIN V2.20
People             : Artificial Intelligence Research Group, University Koblenz
URL                : http://www.uni-koblenz.de/ag-ki/Systems/Protein/
References         : [BF94]  Baumgartner & Furbach (1994), PROTEIN: A PROver wi
                     [BF94]  Baumgartner & Furbach (1994), Model Elimination wi
                     [Bau94] Baumgartner (1994), Refinements of Theory Model El
                     [Bau96] Baumgartner (1996), Linear and Unit-Resulting Refu
                     [BFS97] Baumgartner et al. (1997), Computing Answers with
TPTP release       : v2.0.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f protein
                     (No use of clause type information)
CPU                : 143MHz Sun Ultra 1 and 75MHz SPARCstation 20 MP
RAM size           : 64MB and 300MB
Operating system   : SunOS 5.5.1
Implementation     : Prolog. Compiler: Eclipse Prolog
Resource limits    : 300 seconds
Settings/flags     : Default expect trace switched off   ???
Results format     :     Solns       Time   WCTime
Results values     : Solns   -  P and number of proofs found
                             or TMO-Non
                             or GUP-Non (No solution due to incompleteness)
                     Time    - CPU time, in seconds
                     WCTime  - Wall clock time, in seconds
Results summary    : 1935 problems (3277 in TPTP v2.0.0, 1342 since Bugfixed)
                       212 IAP-Non
                        32 GUP-Non
                       854 TMO-Non
                       837 UNS-Ass
                      1723 tested (89%)
                       837 solutions
                       49% success, over those tested
                       43% success, overall
Comments           : PROTEIN with automated theory handling, as used to
                     establish these results, is incomplete. (Without theory
                     handling PROTEIN is complete, but it would loop e.g. on
                     BOO008-3.)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : DISCOUNT TSM2.1
People             : Stephan Schulz (Term Space Maps, Proof Analysis and
                     Learning, Hacks)
                     Joerg Denzinger (Initial supervision, Calculus)
                     Werner Pitz (Main inference engine)
                     Martin Kronenburg
URL                :
References         : [DS96a] Denzinger & Schulz (1996), Learning Domain Knowled
                     [DS96b] Denzinger & Schulz (1996), Recording and Analysing
                     [DKS97] Denzinger et al. (1997), DISCOUNT: A Distributed a
                     [Sch98] Schultz (1998), Term Space Mapping for DISCOUNT
TPTP release       : v2.1.0
Tested on SPCs     : UEQ
tptp2X flags       : -t rm_equality:rm_eq_rstfp -f otter
CPU                : SparcStation Ultra2/200
RAM size           : 512MB
Operating system   : Solaris 2.5.1
Implementation     : C. Compiler: gcc-2.7.2. Flags: -O6
Resource limits    : 300 seconds.
Settings/flags     : -x otsmstandard -proofs_limit 0.4 -neg_limit 0.8
Results format     :     Solns       Time                               PE
Results values     : Solns -  P and number of proofs found
                           or M and the number of models found
                           or TMO-Non
                     Time  - CPU time, in seconds
                     PE    - Problem Encoding: Universally (A) or Existentially
                             (E) quantified.
Results summary    : 3479 problems (3622 in TPTP v2.1.0, 143 since Bugfixed)
                      3097 IAP-Non
                       113 TMO-Non
                       268 UNS-Ass
                         1 SAT-Ass
                       382 tested (11%)
                       269 solutions
                       70% success, over those tested
                        8% success, overall
Comments           : Used a knowledge base containing 203 problems for learning
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : SCOTT 6.1
People             : Kahlil Hodgson, John Slaney, Ewing Lusk, William McCune
URL                : 
References         : [SH97]  Slaney & Hodgson (1997), Extending SCOTT to use Mu
                     [SLM94] Slaney et al. (1994), SCOTT: Semantically Constrai
                     [Sla93] Slaney (1993), SCOTT: A Model-Guided Theorem Prove
TPTP release       : v3.3.0
tptp2X flags       : -t add_equality:r -f scott:hypothesis:conjecture:none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Implementation     : C.
Resource limits    : 600 seconds
Settings/flags     :  assign(max_num_maxisets, 5).
                      assign(min_num_maxisets,  3).
                      assign(true_weight,       0).
                      assign(sem_queue_limit,          2).
                      assign(min_search_time,        500).
                      assign(max_search_time,       2000).
                      assign(tolerance,          \"1.5\").
                      assign(min_prob_extn,      \"0.3\").
                      assign(cost_margin,       \"10.0\").
                      assign(guidance_factor,    \"5.0\").
                      assign(min_refinement,           0).
                      clear(demod_in_conjecture).
                      clear(demod_in_sem_base).
                      assign(max_int_fails,            2).
                      assign(max_ext_fails,            2).
                      assign(revs_to_skip_on_fail,     2).
                      assign(limit_weight_to,         10).
                      assign(cull_weights_over,       90).
                      assign(memory_control_point, 10000).
                      set(semantic_guidance).
Results format     :     Solns       Time    Given  Clauses  ClsKept
Results values     : Solns   - SZS standard
                     Time    - CPU time, in seconds
                     Given   - Number of given clauses in loop
                     Clauses - Number of clauses generated
                     ClsKept - Number of clauses kept
Results summary    : 9894 problems (9894 in TPTP v3.3.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                       684 UNK-Non
                       694 GUP-Non
                      4320 TMO-Non
                      1174 THM-Ref
                      2513 UNS-Ref
                       136 CSA-Mod
                       373 SAT-Mod
                      9894 tested (100%)
                      4196 solutions
                       42% success, over those tested
                       42% success, overall
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Bliksem 1.12
People             : Hans de Nivelle
URL                : http://www.ii.uni.wroc.pl/~nivelle/software/bliksem
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
tptp2X flags       : -f bliksem -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600
Command/settings   : bliksem %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Generated Kept
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      2298 UNK-Non
                      5162 TMO-Non
                      1259 THM-Ref
                         2 UNS-Ass
                      2674 UNS-Ref
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      3935 solutions
                       35% success, over those tested
                       35% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : CARINE 0.734 
People             : Paul Haroun
URL                : http://www.atpcarine.com/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f carine -t add_equality
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : carine %s t=%d xo=off uct=32000
Results format     : Solns Time  Generated Units
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      5049 IAP-Non
                       739 UNK-Non
                        85 GUP-Non
                      4571 TMO-Non
                       951 UNS-Ref
                      6346 tested (56%)
                       951 solutions
                       15% success, over those tested
                        8% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : CiME 2.01  
People             : Benjamin Monate, Evelyn Contejean
URL                : http://cime.lri.fr/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF_UEQ
tptp2X flags       : -f oldtptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : tptp2cime %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                     10532 IAP-Non
                         4 UNK-Non
                       357 TMO-Non
                       493 UNS-Ass
                         9 SAT-Sat
                       863 tested (8%)
                       502 solutions
                       58% success, over those tested
                        4% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Darwin 1.4.3 
People             : Alexander Fuchs, Peter Baumgartner, Cesare Tinelli
URL                : http://goedel.cs.uiowa.edu/Darwin/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp:short -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : darwin -pl 0 -pmc true -to %d %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                        57 UNK-Non
                      6632 TMO-Non
                      1593 THM-Ass
                      2349 UNS-Ass
                       256 CSA-Mod
                       508 SAT-Mod
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      4706 solutions
                       41% success, over those tested
                       41% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Sat Jul 26 03:48:48 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : DarwinFM 1.4.3 
People             : Alexander Fuchs, Peter Baumgartner, Cesare Tinelli
URL                : http://goedel.cs.uiowa.edu/Darwin/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF_NKT FOF_NKU CNF_NKU
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp:short -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : darwin -fd true -ppp true -pl 0 -to %d -pmtptp true %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      8960 IAP-Non
                         1 UNK-Non
                      1332 TMO-Non
                       333 CSA-FMo
                       769 SAT-FMo
                      2435 tested (21%)
                      1102 solutions
                       45% success, over those tested
                       10% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Sat Jul 26 11:35:55 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : DCTP 1.31  
People             : Gernot Stenz, Reinhold Letz
URL                : 
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f oldtptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : dctp-wrapper -negpref -complexity -fullrewrite -alternate -resisol %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Linkings ClausesInTableau
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      5049 IAP-Non
                       746 UNK-Non
                       587 GUP-Non
                      1787 TMO-Non
                      2723 UNS-Ass
                       503 SAT-Ass
                      6346 tested (56%)
                      3226 solutions
                       51% success, over those tested
                       28% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : E 1.0pre
People             : Stephan Schulz
URL                : http://www.eprover.org/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp:raw -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : eprover -s --print-statistics -xAuto -tAuto --cpu-limit=%d --memory-limit=Auto --tstp-in %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Generated NonTrivial Processed
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                         1 UNK-Non
                      4082 TMO-Non
                      2437 THM-Ass
                      4082 UNS-Ass
                       309 CSA-Ass
                       484 SAT-Ass
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      7312 solutions
                       64% success, over those tested
                       64% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : E-KRHyper 1.1  
People             : Bjorn Pelzer
URL                : http://www.uni-koblenz.de/~bpelzer/ekrhyper/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : casc/ekrhyper %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Disjuntcions Depth Closed Evaluations
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      5049 IAP-Non
                      4120 UNK-Non
                        77 TMO-Non
                      1939 UNS-CRf
                       210 SAT-Ass
                      6346 tested (56%)
                      2149 solutions
                       34% success, over those tested
                       19% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : EQP 0.9d  
People             : William McCune
URL                : http://www.cs.unm.edu/~mccune/eqp/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF_UEQ
tptp2X flags       : -f eqp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : eqp_wrapper %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Clauses Given
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                     10532 IAP-Non
                       321 UNK-Non
                         1 TMO-Non
                       541 UNS-Ref
                       863 tested (8%)
                       541 solutions
                       63% success, over those tested
                        5% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Equinox 1.3   
People             : Koen Claessen
URL                : http://www.cs.chalmers.se/~koen/folkung/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp:short -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : equinox --tstp --split %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                       108 UNK-Non
                       788 GUP-Non
                      6476 TMO-Non
                      1878 THM-Ass
                      2145 UNS-Ass
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      4023 solutions
                       35% success, over those tested
                       35% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Fampire 1.3   
People             : Josef Urban
URL                : http://dreamers.com/lichlair/imagenes/bloodredmoon3.jpg
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.11-1.1369_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : FlotterOnTPTP.pl -f oldtptp -s vampire -t %d %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      6346 IAP-Non
                      2239 UNK-Non
                       304 TMO-Non
                      2338 THM-Ass
                        78 UNS-Ass
                        72 CSA-Ass
                        18 SAT-Ass
                      5049 tested (44%)
                      2506 solutions
                       50% success, over those tested
                       22% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Faust 1.0   
People             : Yury Puzis
URL                : http://umsis.miami.edu/~ypuzis/FAUST-AutomatedTheoremProver.html
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2794MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.11-1.1369_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : faust %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      4640 UNK-Non
                      4868 TMO-Non
                       595 THM-Ref
                         5 THM-Ass
                      1287 UNS-Ref
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      1887 solutions
                       17% success, over those tested
                       17% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : FDP 0.9.16
People             : Peter Baumgartner
URL                : 
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f protein -t add_equality
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : fdp-casc %s %d
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      5049 IAP-Non
                      1169 UNK-Non
                       168 GUP-Non
                      2700 TMO-Non
                      1904 UNS-Ass
                       405 SAT-Ass
                      6346 tested (56%)
                      2309 solutions
                       36% success, over those tested
                       20% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : Flags: -q -a
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Fiesta 2     
People             : Robert Nieuwenhuis
URL                : 
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF_UEQ
tptp2X flags       : -f dedam -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : fiesta-wrapper %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Memory
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                     10532 IAP-Non
                        40 UNK-Non
                       230 TMO-Non
                       593 UNS-Ref
                       863 tested (8%)
                       593 solutions
                       69% success, over those tested
                        5% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Gandalf c-2.6 
People             : Tanel Tammet
URL                : http://www.ttu.ee/it/gandalf/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given) -t add_equality:r
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : gandalf-wrapper -time %d %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Given Derived Kept
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      5049 IAP-Non
                      2460 UNK-Non
                       311 TMO-Non
                      3575 UNS-Ass
                      6346 tested (56%)
                      3575 solutions
                       56% success, over those tested
                       31% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Geo 2007f 
People             : Hans de Nivelle
URL                : http://www.ii.uni.wroc.pl/~nivelle/software/geo/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : geo -nonempty -tptp_input -inputfile %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                       749 UNK-Non
                        93 GUP-Non
                      6090 TMO-Non
                      1264 THM-Ref
                      2261 UNS-Ref
                       318 CSA-Mod
                       620 SAT-Mod
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      4463 solutions
                       39% success, over those tested
                       39% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : GrAnDe 1.1   
People             : Stephan Schulz, Geoff Sutcliffe
URL                : http://www.cs.miami.edu/~tptp/ATPSystems/GrAnDe/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF_EPR
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t add_equality+cnf:otter
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : And %s %d
Results format     : Solns Time  EStatus
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                     10612 IAP-Non
                       181 UNK-Non
                         5 TMO-Non
                       453 UNS-Ass
                       144 SAT-Ass
                       783 tested (7%)
                       597 solutions
                       76% success, over those tested
                        5% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : eground: --tptp-in --dimacs --silent --resources-info
                              --split-tries=100 --memory-limit=400
                              --soft-cpu-limit=%d --add-one-instance
                              --constraints
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : iProver 0.5crv
People             : Konstantin Korovin
URL                : http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/~korovink/iprover/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : iproveropt --eprover_path /home/graph/tptp/Systems/iProver---0.5crv/ %s
Results format     : Solns Time  ILoops RLoops PropCalls
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                       844 UNK-Non
                        51 GUP-Non
                      4532 TMO-Non
                      2216 THM-Ass
                      2827 UNS-Ass
                       312 CSA-Ass
                       613 SAT-Ass
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      5968 solutions
                       52% success, over those tested
                       52% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 08:41:22 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : leanCoP 2.0   
People             : Jens Otten, Thomas Raths
URL                : http://www.leancop.de/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f leancop -t stdfof+add_equality
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : leancop.sh %s %d
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      1451 UNK-Non
                      6231 TMO-Non
                      1789 THM-Ass
                      1716 UNS-Ass
                        69 CSA-Ass
                       139 SAT-Ass
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      3713 solutions
                       33% success, over those tested
                       33% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : LeanTAP 2.3   
People             : Bernhard Beckert
URL                : http://www.uni-koblenz.de/~beckert/leantap/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f leantap -t add_equality
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2794MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.11-1.1369_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : leantap %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      3851 UNK-Non
                      6901 TMO-Non
                       328 THM-Ass
                       315 UNS-Ass
                     11395 tested (100%)
                       643 solutions
                        6% success, over those tested
                        6% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Mace2 2.2   
People             : William McCune
URL                : http://www.cs.unm.edu/~mccune/otter/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF_NKU FOF_NKT FOF_NKU
tptp2X flags       : -f otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given) -t add_equality:r
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : mace-script %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Size
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      8963 IAP-Non
                       995 GUP-Non
                       861 TMO-Non
                       102 CSA-Mod
                         3 CSA-FMo
                       470 SAT-Mod
                         1 SAT-FMo
                      2432 tested (21%)
                       576 solutions
                       24% success, over those tested
                        5% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : Flags: -N 12 -p -k 100000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Mace4 1207  
People             : William McCune
URL                : http://www.cs.unm.edu/~mccune/prover9/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF_NKU FOF_NKT FOF_NKU
tptp2X flags       : -f prover9:[set(print_models_portable)] -t stdfof
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : mace4 -c -N -1 -t %d -f %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Size
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      8963 IAP-Non
                       405 UNK-Non
                      1203 TMO-Non
                       204 CSA-FMo
                       620 SAT-FMo
                      2432 tested (21%)
                       824 solutions
                       34% success, over those tested
                        7% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Matita 0.1.0 
People             : Andrea Asperti
URL                : http://matita.cs.unibo.it/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF_UEQ
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.11-1.1369_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : DoMatita %d %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                     10532 IAP-Non
                        67 UNK-Non
                       274 TMO-Non
                       522 UNS-Ref
                       863 tested (8%)
                       522 solutions
                       60% success, over those tested
                        5% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Metis 2.1   
People             : Joe Hurd
URL                : http://www.gilith.com/software/metis
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : metis --show proof --show saturation %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      1667 UNK-Non
                      5311 TMO-Non
                      1557 THM-CRf
                      2183 UNS-CRf
                       276 CSA-Ass
                       379 SAT-Ass
                        22 SAT-Sat
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      4417 solutions
                       39% success, over those tested
                       39% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Muscadet 2.7a  
People             : Dominique Pastre
URL                : http://www.math-info.univ-paris5.fr/~pastre/muscadet/muscadet.html
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : muscadet %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      6346 IAP-Non
                       118 UNK-Non
                       575 GUP-Non
                      3184 TMO-Non
                      1164 THM-Ass
                         8 UNS-Ass
                      5049 tested (44%)
                      1172 solutions
                       23% success, over those tested
                       10% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Otter 3.3   
People             : William McCune
URL                : http://www.cs.unm.edu/~mccune/otter/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f otter -t add_equality:r
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2794MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.11-1.1369_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : otter-script %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Given Generated Kept
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                         3 UNK-Non
                      5989 GUP-Non
                      1694 TMO-Non
                      1279 THM-Ref
                      2430 UNS-Ref
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      3709 solutions
                       33% success, over those tested
                       33% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : Flags: set(prolog_style_variables) set(auto) set(tptp_eq)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Paradox 2.3   
People             : Koen Claessen
URL                : http://www.cs.chalmers.se/~koen/folkung/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF_NKT FOF_NKU_NUN CNF_NKU
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp:short -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : paradox --tstp --model %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Size
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      8954 IAP-Non
                       198 UNK-Non
                      1131 TMO-Non
                       329 CSA-FMo
                       783 SAT-FMo
                      2441 tested (21%)
                      1112 solutions
                       46% success, over those tested
                       10% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Prover9 1207  
People             : William McCune
URL                : http://www.cs.unm.edu/~mccune/prover9/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f prover9 -t stdfof
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : prover9 -t %d -f %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Given Generated Kept
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      1288 UNK-Non
                       864 GUP-Non
                      4231 TMO-Non
                      1678 THM-Ref
                      3334 UNS-Ref
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      5012 solutions
                       44% success, over those tested
                       44% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : randoCoP 2.0   
People             : Jens Otten, Thomas Raths
URL                : 
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f leancop -t stdfof+add_equality
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : randocop.sh %s %d
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                       974 UNK-Non
                      6697 TMO-Non
                      2079 THM-Ass
                      1495 UNS-Ass
                        14 CSA-Ass
                       136 SAT-Ass
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      3724 solutions
                       33% success, over those tested
                       33% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : SETHEO 3.3   
People             : Reinhold Letz
URL                : http://www4.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~letz/setheo/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f setheo -t add_equality
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1000MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : setheo-wrapper %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Inferences
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      5049 IAP-Non
                       348 UNK-Non
                      2334 GUP-Non
                      1867 TMO-Non
                      1797 UNS-Ass
                      6346 tested (56%)
                      1797 solutions
                       28% success, over those tested
                       16% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : Flags: inwasm -cons -foldup, sam -dr -cons
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : S-SETHEO 0.0   
People             : Reinhold Letz
URL                : http://www4.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~letz/setheo/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f oldtptp -t add_equality
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : scheme-setheo -norel -foldup -sgindex -indexfoldup -reg -mate -dynsgreord 0 %s
Results format     : Solns Time  ProofLength Inferences
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      5049 IAP-Non
                      4211 UNK-Non
                       216 TMO-Non
                      1919 UNS-Ass
                      6346 tested (56%)
                      1919 solutions
                       30% success, over those tested
                       17% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : SNARK 20070805 
People             : Mark Stickel
URL                : http://www.ai.sri.com/~stickel/snark.html
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : run-snark %s %d
Results format     : Solns Time  Derived Kept Answers
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      3039 UNK-Non
                       432 GUP-Non
                      3421 TMO-Non
                      1719 THM-Ref
                      2784 UNS-Ref
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      4503 solutions
                       40% success, over those tested
                       40% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : This is SNARK release 20070805r043
                   : Settings/flags:
                     Agenda length 3000
                     (default-use-hyperresolution t)
                     (default-use-paramodulation t)
                     (default-use-factoring :pos)
                     (default-use-literal-ordering-with-hyperresolution
                         'literal-ordering-p)
                     (default-use-literal-ordering-with-paramodulation
                         'literal-ordering-p)
                     (default-print-rows-when-given nil)
                     (default-print-rows-when-derived nil)
                     (default-run-time-limit 600)
                     (default-listen-for-commands nil)
                     (default-use-kif-rewrites nil)
                     (default-use-closure-when-satisfiable nil)
                   : The strategy is incomplete, so no solution does not
                     indicate satisfiability. If the propositional abstraction
                     of a problem is satisfiable, existence of a model is
                     reported.
                   : Commutative unification is used for commutative function
                     and predicate symbols. Associative-commutative unification
                     is used for associative-commutative function symbols.
                     Commutativity and associativity axioms in the problems are
                     detected automatically.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : SOS 2.0   
People             : John Slaney
URL                : http://users.rsise.anu.edu.au/~jks/software/sos2.tar.gz
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given) -t add_equality:r
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : sos-script %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      2229 UNK-Non
                       460 GUP-Non
                      4610 TMO-Non
                      1347 THM-Ref
                      2749 UNS-Ref
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      4096 solutions
                       36% success, over those tested
                       36% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : SPASS 3.01  
People             : Christoph Weidenbach
URL                : http://spass.mpi-sb.mpg.de/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f dfg -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : SPASS -PGiven=0 -PProblem=0 -DocProof -TimeLimit=%d %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Memory Derived Kept Used
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      1955 UNK-Non
                         9 GUP-Non
                      3391 TMO-Non
                      2126 THM-Ref
                      3147 UNS-Ref
                       302 CSA-Ass
                       465 SAT-Ass
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      6040 solutions
                       53% success, over those tested
                       53% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : SRASS 0.1   
People             : Geoff Sutcliffe
URL                : http://www.cs.miami.edu/~tptp/ATPSystems/SRASS/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : SRASS -q2 -a 0 10 10 10 -i3 -n60 %s
Results format     : Solns Time  Selected Unselected
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      6346 IAP-Non
                       824 UNK-Non
                      1870 TMO-Non
                      2307 THM-Sol
                        48 THM-Ass
                      5049 tested (44%)
                      2355 solutions
                       47% success, over those tested
                       21% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Theo 2006  
People             : Monty Newborn
URL                : 
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : theo %s -l L1 w0 t%d
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      2879 UNK-Non
                       597 GUP-Non
                      4313 TMO-Non
                      1277 THM-Ref
                         7 UNS-Ass
                      2322 UNS-Ref
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      3606 solutions
                       32% success, over those tested
                       32% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Vampire 9.0   
People             : Andrei Voronkov
URL                : http://www.vampire.fm
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF CNF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp:short -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : jumpirefix --output_syntax tptp -t %d %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                       650 UNK-Non
                       841 GUP-Non
                      2965 TMO-Non
                      2559 THM-Ref
                         2 THM-Ass
                         1 UNS-Ass
                      4271 UNS-Ref
                       106 SAT-Ass
                     11395 tested (100%)
                      6939 solutions
                       61% success, over those tested
                       61% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Waldmeister 806
People             : Thomas Hillenbrand, Bernd Loechner (WEC)
URL                : http://www.waldmeister.org/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF_UEQ
tptp2X flags       : -f waldmeister -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.11-1.1369_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : WaldmeisterII.comp %s
Results format     : Solns Time  
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                     10532 IAP-Non
                         2 UNK-Non
                         2 GUP-Non
                       168 TMO-Non
                       686 UNS-Ref
                         3 SAT-Ass
                         2 SAT-Sat
                       863 tested (8%)
                       691 solutions
                       80% success, over those tested
                        6% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : zChaff 04.11.15
People             : Sharad Malik
URL                : http://www.princeton.edu/~chaff
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : CNF_PRP
tptp2X flags       : -f dimacs -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : zchaff %s %d
Results format     : Solns Time  MaxDecisionLevel NumDecisions
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                     11350 IAP-Non
                        37 UNS-Ass
                         8 SAT-Ass
                        45 tested (0%)
                        45 solutions
                      100% success, over those tested
                        0% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATP system name    : Zenon 0.5.0 
People             : Richard Bonichon, David Delahaye, Damien Doligez
URL                : http://focal.inria.fr/zenon/
TPTP release       : v3.5.0
Tested on SPCs     : FOF
tptp2X flags       : -f tptp -t none
CPU                : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
RAM size           : 1003MB
Operating system   : Linux 2.6.17-1.2142_FC4
Resource limits    : 600s
Command/settings   : zenon -itptp -p0 -stats -ocoq -max-time %ds %s
Results format     : Solns Time  NodesSearch MaxBranchF ProofNodes Formulas
Results summary    : 11395 problems (11395 in TPTP v3.5.0, 0 since Bugfixed)
                      6346 IAP-Non
                       107 UNK-Non
                      2763 GUP-Non
                      1083 TMO-Non
                      1011 THM-Prf
                        85 UNS-Prf
                      5049 tested (44%)
                      1011 solutions
                       20% success, over those tested
                        9% success, overall
Submitted by       : Geoff Sutcliffe
Inserted           : Tue Jul 22 06:06:34 EDT 2008
Comments           : 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------