System: Bliksem Version: 1.12a URL: http://www.mpi-sb.mpg.de/~bliksem/ Command: bliksem %s Format: bliksem Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: found a proof! NonThm: dummy_never_found NoSoln: found a saturation! StartSoln: START OF PROOF EndSoln: END OF PROOF CASCDiv: MIX UEQ FOF CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/bliksem Status: READY System: CiME Version: 2 URL: http://cime.lri.fr/ Command: cime-wrapper %s Format: tptp Transform: none Theorem: is_unsatisfiable : bool = true NonThm: Never find this now is_unsatisfiable : bool = false NoSoln: dummy_never_found CASCDiv: UEQ CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: DCTP Version: 1.2 URL: http://wwwjessen.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~stenzg/dctp.html Command: dctp-wrapper -negpref -complexity -alternate -resisol -fullrewrite %s Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: PROOF NonThm: MODEL NoSoln: ERROR CASCDiv: MIX CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: DCTP Version: 1.2-SAT URL: http://wwwjessen.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~stenzg/dctp.html Command: dctp-wrapper -alternate -resisol -fullrewrite %s Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: PROOF NonThm: MODEL NoSoln: ERROR CASCDiv: SAT CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: DCTP Version: 1.2-EPR URL: http://wwwjessen.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~stenzg/dctp.html Command: dctp-wrapper -negpref -oweight 2 -cweight 2 -alternate -resisol -fullrewrite %s Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: PROOF NonThm: MODEL NoSoln: ERROR CASCDiv: EPR CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: DCTP Version: 10.1p URL: http://wwwjessen.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~stenzg/dctp.html Command: bin/dctp-10.1p %s %d Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: PROOF NonThm: MODEL NoSoln: ERROR CASCDiv: MIX FOF EPR CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: DCTP Version: 10.1p-SAT URL: http://wwwjessen.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~stenzg/dctp.html Command: bin/dctp-10.1p-sat %s %d Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: PROOF NonThm: MODEL NoSoln: ERROR CASCDiv: SAT CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: E Version: 0.7 URL: http://wwwjessen.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~schulz/WORK/eprover.html Command: eprover -s -xAuto -tAuto --memory-limit=384 --tptp-in --cpu-limit=%d %s Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: Proof found! NonThm: No proof found! NoSoln: Failure: CASCDiv: MIX UEQ CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: EP Version: 0.7 URL: http://wwwjessen.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~schulz/WORK/eprover.html Command: eproof -xAuto -tAuto --memory-limit=384 --tptp-in --cpu-limit=%d %s Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: "proof" NonThm: "final" NoSoln: Cannot determine problem status within resource limit StartSoln: Proof status evidence starts here EndSoln: Proof status evidence ends here CASCDiv: MIX CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: E-SETHEO Version: csp02 URL: http://www8.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~setheo/ Command: bin/run-e-setheo %s %d Format: tptp Transform: none Theorem: SUCCESS (proof NonThm: SUCCESS (model NoSoln: FAIL (resources CASCDiv: MIX UEQ FOF EPR CASCProb: NoTransform/tptp Status: READY System: E-SETHEO Version: csp02-SAT URL: http://www8.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~setheo/ Command: bin/run-e-setheo-sat %s %d Format: tptp Transform: none Theorem: SUCCESS (proof NonThm: SUCCESS (model NoSoln: FAIL (resources CASCDiv: SAT CASCProb: NoTransform/tptp Status: READY System: Gandalf Version: c-2.5 URL: http://www.cs.chalmers.se/~tammet/gandalf/ Command: gandalf-wrapper %s %d Format: otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given),set(tptp_eq) Transform: rm_equality:stfp Theorem: EMPTY NonThm: SATISFIABLE NoSoln: time limit exhausted: proof search terminated CASCDiv: MIX UEQ CASCProb: RmEq_stfp/otter_auto Status: READY System: Gandalf Version: c-2.5-PROOF URL: http://www.cs.chalmers.se/~tammet/gandalf/ Command: gandalf-wrapper -proof %s %d Format: otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given),set(tptp_eq) Transform: rm_equality:stfp Theorem: EMPTY NonThm: SATISFIABLE NoSoln: time limit exhausted: proof search terminated StartSoln: START OF PROOF EndSoln: END OF PROOF CASCDiv: MIX CASCProb: RmEq_stfp/otter_auto Status: READY System: Gandalf Version: c-2.5-SAT URL: http://www.cs.chalmers.se/~tammet/gandalf/ Command: gandalf-wrapper -sat %s %d Format: otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given),set(tptp_eq) Transform: rm_equality:stfp Theorem: EMPTY NonThm: SATISFIABLE NoSoln: time limit exhausted: proof search terminated CASCDiv: SAT EPR CASCProb: RmEq_stfp/otter_auto Status: READY System: GandalfSat Version: 1.0 URL: Command: gandalf-wrapper -sat %s %d Format: otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given) Transform: rm_equality:stfp Theorem: EMPTY NonThm: SATISFIABLE NoSoln: time limit exhausted: proof search terminated CASCDiv: SAT CASCProb: RmEq_stfp/otter_auto Status: READY System: GrAnDe Version: 1.1 URL: http://www.cs.miami.edu/~tptp/ATPSystems/GrAnDe/ Command: And %s %d Format: tptp Transform: none Theorem: Instance unsatisfiable NonThm: Instance satisfiable NoSoln: Not enough time to decide CASCDiv: EPR CASCProb: NoTransform/tptp Status: READY System: ICGNS Version: 2002b URL: http://www.mcs.anl.gov/~mccune/icgns Command: icgns-for-tptp %s Format: otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given) Transform: rm_equality:stfp Theorem: dummy_never_found NonThm: SATISFIABLE NoSoln: FAILURE StartSoln: Model 1 EndSoln: end of model CASCDiv: SAT CASCProb: RmEq_stfp/otter_auto Status: READY System: Otter Version: 3.2 URL: http://www.mcs.anl.gov/home/mccune/ar/otter Command: otter-script %s Format: otter:none:set(auto),clear(print_given) ForCASC: ,set(build_proof_object_2) Transform: rm_equality:stfp Theorem: ---------------- PROOF ---------------- NonThm: dummy_never_found NoSoln: PROOF NOT FOUND StartSoln: ---------------- PROOF ---------------- EndSoln: ------------ end of proof ------------- CASCDiv: MIX UEQ FOF CASCProb: RmEq_stfp/otter_auto Status: READY System: SCOTT Version: 6.1 URL: http://discus.anu.edu.au/software/scott/ Command: scott-wrapper %d %s Format: scott:hypothesis:conjecture:none Transform: rm_equality:stfp+stdfof Theorem: ---------------- PROOF ---------------- NonThm: Model checks out NoSoln: Search stopped because sos empty StartSoln: ---------------- PROOF ---------------- EndSoln: ------------ end of proof ------------- CASCDiv: MIX UEQ SAT FOF EPR CASCProb: RmEq_stfp/scott Status: READY System: Vampire Version: 5.0 URL: http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/~riazanoa/Vampire/ Command: vampire -t %d --casc on %s Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: Proof found. Thanks to Tanya! NonThm: Unprovable NoSoln: I would definitely solve this problem if I had one more second StartSoln: ====== Proof: ====== EndSoln: ===== End of proof. ==== CASCDiv: MIX UEQ FOF EPR CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: Vampire Version: 5.0-CASC URL: http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/~riazanoa/Vampire/ Command: vampire -t %d --casc on --tune on %s Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: Proof found. Thanks to Tanya! NonThm: Unprovable NoSoln: I would definitely solve this problem if I had one more second StartSoln: ====== Proof: ====== EndSoln: ===== End of proof. ==== CASCDiv: MIX CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: Vampire Version: 2.0-CASC URL: http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/~riazanoa/Vampire/ Command: vampire-CASC %d %s Format: tptp Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: Proof found NonThm: dummy_never_found NoSoln: Proof not found StartSoln: ======================== Proof: ========================= EndSoln: ================== End of proof. ======================== CASCDiv: MIX CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/tptp Status: READY System: Waldmeister Version: 601 URL: http://www-avenhaus.informatik.uni-kl.de/waldmeister Command: WaldmeisterII.comp %s Format: waldmeister Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: Goal proved NonThm: System completed NoSoln: Unfair completion run out of critical pairs StartSoln: P R O O F P R O T O C O L EndSoln: Waldmeister states: Goal proved CASCDiv: UEQ CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/waldmeister Status: READY System: Waldmeister Version: 702 URL: http://www-avenhaus.informatik.uni-kl.de/waldmeister Command: WaldmeisterII.comp %s Format: waldmeister Transform: rm_equality:rstfp Theorem: Goal proved NonThm: System completed NoSoln: Unfair completion run out of critical pairs StartSoln: P R O O F P R O T O C O L EndSoln: Waldmeister states: Goal proved CASCDiv: UEQ CASCProb: RmEq_rstfp/waldmeister Status: READY